19 comments so far
Got the book but haven’t read it yet.
Some reasons I think men give up on church …
Some of our songs are hopeless for men eg Darling of heaven – I am never singing that!
Too much touchy feely stuff that doesn’t relate to men – men are emotional but often express it in diff ways to women
Not enough hands on practical involvement
Lack of men only groups
& as you said – lack of risk, playing it safe
Just a few random thoughts
John Finkeldes last blog post..Subiaco premiers again
Thanks for your comments Pastor John Finkelde. Hope you enjoy your stay hear. I would recommend the book as it is very direct and it will challenge you the way you do church. I know its challenged the way I think about church.
Thanks for your random thoughts as they are all spot on…
Some of our songs are hopeless for men eg Darling of heaven – I am never singing that!
I tend to agree. One of my biggest ‘issues’ with the church world is the music of today. Yesterdays worship music was all about God, the Blood, Jesus, the Holy Spirit etc but todays? Its all about me, I, we etc..
Too much touchy feely stuff that doesn’t relate to men – men are emotional but often express it in diff ways to women
And John, what would you say are ways men relate their emotions? For me, when I have lead groups at Jubilee. I find the things that open men up for emotions are:
- Open up first and they will open up.
- Food.
- Sport activities.
Lack of men only groups
Again totally agree, did you know most churches have more activities for the youth, kids, women and elderly than the Men. Jesus reached the Men first yet we (the church) try and reach them last.
Thanks again for your thoughts Ps John.
GermWorkss last blog post..Wrap up of AFL finals 2008 week 3
Jermayn, this is shows excellent discernment on your part. It’s a huge issue which, sadly, many are ignoring.
One of the reasons men don’t attend church is because they are less tolerant (than women) of useless preaching, and they tend to be put off when they discern hypocrisy (women may discern it too, but they are usually more forgiving).
Another reason may be because society has taught that women don’t need men, and the church hasn’t rebuked that lie. If men were taught that they are needed, that their wives and children depend upon them to lead, teach, and provide, then they would be more interested in learning from biblical preaching which would teach them how to do these things appropriately.
Above all, the preacher in the pulpit must be a man, and he must exercise a masculine ministry.
@Armen – All preachers must be men? Boy you like rocking the boat dont ya? I would love to see your reasons on that (You can always guest post for me
).
I agree that todays society of feminism is a good reason why men are not around but the interesting thing is that Men started disappearing from churches well before the feminism movement 30-40 years ago.
Men started disappearing back in the 1300’s which is the earliest documentation of church numbers.
I think the lack of risk and excitement is HUGE, Today in certain non-Christian countries (Iran, Pakistan etc) and back in the pre-Roman Catholic days, men numbers were and are up. I think todays Western Christian men are just bored and most see the Football, the pub, working at the mines and sleeping in more exciting than going to church.
Sometimes I tend to agree….
GermWorkss last blog post..Did you know: Brownlow Medal winners
I’m not saying that women can’t speak the gospel, but when it comes to pastor/minister/bishop/elder (whatever term you want to use), the Bible is clear – men only!
The reason is simple – can a woman be the husband of one wife? (1 Tim 3:2; Tit 1:6).
Armens last blog post..50 Things You (probably) Never Knew About Me
nah I agree Armen.
However in saying that I do think Women have a place to speak and minister to people especially to other women. I think they minister better to other women than what men can do.
I think this is actually another reason why Men struggle in churches and that is due to the fact that they are under women. Most men will NOT follow or be discipled by women. Men will only follow other men..
Sounds great looking forward to it ! this is really nice mate! good job! Thanx!
Ryan Jins last blog post..Ja Tabs From Joomlart 1.5.7
Hi Jermayn,
The abscence of men at Church is the fruit of a number of greater problems:
1. Most Christians send their children to Caesar to be educated (i.e. discipled, see Lk. 6:46). Our school systems teach gender neutrality and feed our children with blatent humanism. So when they grow up most Christian children leave Church (NCLS studies show 95% of christian children at age 15 walk away from the faith). We must disciple our children in a full Christian life philosphy or they will continue leaving the Church in droves.
2. The purpose of Church has been blurred in the last century. Sunday services are not primarily about us and our entertainement. Sunday services are about God’s people coming before him in corporate worship, as prescribed and described in the Bible. When we run our services like a “rock concert” or entertainment show, trying to be “seeker friendly” we anger God and He judges us.
3. Agreed with some comments that the Church has become effeminate. This has been cultivated through sending our children to Caesar. Humanism teaches there is no distinction between man and woman, we are ultimately equal. So we see, in society, girls growing up to be tomboys and boys growing up to be very effeminate. Again, the Church needs to reclaim education and take a stand for God honoring discipleship of boys to be men and girls woman (not men with the biological capacity to have children).
4. Point 3 affirms what you answered to Armen in #6. Woman can disciple younger women, in the things disclosed in Titus 2 (e.g. teaching children, how to be a maker of the home etc.). But men (husbands) need to disciple their own wife in the word (Eph 5) and wash her with it. So, I agree with you: when the Church immitates the world re: men must submit to women, men will leave the Church (and have done) in droves.
What must be done. Preachers must stop being infactuated with justification alone and move on to teach the people of God to be the people of God in doctrine and lifestyle. Men need to be challenged, from the pulpit, to live their God ordained responsibilities.
Trev
Point 2 is very interesting and I have touched upon it before and you are right. Church is not about our entertainment but rather to come together in fellowship and worship God.
I also agree with gender equality, while men and women are equal. Men are different than women – doh!
and its the same at school. Boys cannot sit still in a class (& church), the modern school & church has been designed for women. You sit down, you get taught “open book”, you stand when told, you open your mouth when told and the men?? Well if they are even there physically, they are not spiritually…
Thanks for your comments Trev and I would welcome you to continue commenting and I hope you enjoy your stay
GermWorkss last blog post..Body of Lies
Jermayn,
Boys can’t sit still because of ill discipline in the home. We home school our children and my son (7 y/o) sits well when learning and through the 1 hr plus worship service each Sunday.
The modern school was designed by men like G Stanley Hall (and friends) to mirror the evolutionary Recapitulation Theory…children follow the steps of evolutions and evolve more than their parents and older sibblings. Therefore, children must be age segregated. The Church has followed this model by in large; segregating the child from the parent through Sunday School! Children don’t sit still because they have never been taught/discipled to sit still!
If children are age segregated to Sunday School, how do we expect them to seemlesly intergrate back into Worship?
I would say that our Church services and schools are derived more from a Greek mindset than a Hebrew mindset. The Greek mindset over emphasises abstract theories, with minimum apprenticeship. The Hebrew model emphasis is both on theory and parental apprentice/discipleship…i.e. learn your life philosophy (grounded upon Jesus Christ) in theory and in practice (i.e. while walking in the way…Deut. 6, cf. Luke 6:40).
Worship services have been influenced by feminism, but I think the door was opened by Greek philosophy pervading the Church.
Re: Point 2 – it is very interesting/sad that many modern churches seem to mirror what is seen in the world of heathen entertainment! Much of what has been introduced to the liturgy over the past century has been a copy (a bad one at that) of the Greek amphitheatre. This seems to be a far cry from the order Paul was talking of in his letter to the Church at Corinth. The humbleness and power of the early church, reformers and great awakening seems to have been lost to bands and dancing girls!
PS…thanks for the note. I did enjoy the stay. Will return as I can. Please visit me at http://www.anselmstudyhouse.com.
Trev
OK guys my turn
@ Armen – male pastors/elders/bishiops cos of 1 Tim 3:2 – actually Jesus would fail to qualify if you applied this!?!?! As for Paul himself … I think your exegesis lacks contextual understanding
@ Trev – interestingly in Australia the rise of Christian education in the last 20+years has been immense – strangely we still see a crisis amongst young adults departing church. So I’d question your theory. On entertainment I don’t know any pastor who is focussed on entertaining people as against leading them into connection with God & others.
John Finkeldes last blog post..Geek week at John Finkelde!
Thanks guys for your views and further input on this discussion. It is great..
@John – was Paul actually married at one stage? I have heard from some people/ scholars that he was.
@Trev & John – I personally doubt the problem is actually secular or even Christian schools. I see the problem as the school structure in itself.
In a Dobson book (think – Straight Talk to Men) he talks about how the school system has changed from the early and mid 20 century to todays. The actual school system is NOT designed for men/ boys. I am glad Trev that your son is different but most are not.
I like the sound of the Hebrew school and I think something between that and what we have currently would be ideal. Men need to get out of the class room more.
@ John, while I did not go to a Christian school (I am glad I did not) most that I know off (from siblings and friends), there is not much difference between the secular and Christian school (education & sinful influences).
John,
1. Christian Education has increased in Australia. However, according to NCLS 80% of our children are still sent to the state for their education. The current education system, state based and controlled, was fought tooth and nail by men like Bishop Broughton in the 19th century (see Clark’s history of Australia).
Now, even if Christian education has increased exponentially the majority of children go to Caesar for their education. So why are we surprised when they come back as Romans?
Let’s grant you further grace, say all Christians educate their children in a Christian School and we still have the same problem. Does this mean we abandon the wisdom and truth of the Bible? Do we ignore the injunction to train our children in the way they should go, instructing them all of the time in a Biblical worldview, teaching them to honor God in all things and preparing them as arrows in the hands of a warrior? We would be foolish to think the Biblical mandate is wrong. Rather, in our sinfulness we have failed.
As fathers, we need to get on our knees and repent before God, take our children out of schools and begin to walk with them in the way…when we rise up, during the day and when we lie down.
For too long too many Christian parents have relegated their children’s “secular” education to the state and their “religious” education to the Sunday School. The Bible does not allow these positions and that is why many (NCLS say 95% of 15 y/o people from Christian homes) walk away from the faith every year.
The crisis is still here because we now want trained professionals to do our God ordained tasks as father and mother. We want the “Christian” teacher (who often holds to the view that we are merely higher evolved animals) and Sunday School Teacher (who is often in there teens or has no children of their own) to disciple our children. And we wonder why there is a problem.
I would argue that what I am saying is not a theory but a simple reading of God’s Word and how to apply it like many of God’s people have for centuries.
Better Youth Church Programs will not fix the problem, parents on their knees in prayer and teaching their children will be a start.
Education is one part of the solution…not all of it. Repentance and faithful obedience is needed in many areas of life. Also, if we faithfully apply God’s Word we may only see changes in the next generation or later – for He curses up to 4 generations of those who turn their back on His Word.
I don’t know, maybe the feminist lie that you can have a full time career and family has been bought. You can’t. The most glorious calling for a woman is motherhood and it is shunned today. Or maybe people (like I used to) would prefer to be financially secure with two incomes than to have mum stay home with the children?
I don’t know any pastor who intentionally moves towards an entertainment show for worship. Why? Because I do not know their hearts (Deut 29:29) and am not that sinical!!
But the question over liturgy is interesting. In my limited experience most pastors do not critically evaluate their liturgy (using the Bible as their only standard). Thus, we see many well meaning Churches become seeker friendly entertainment amphitheatres!
My point 1 in post #8 quoted Luke 6:46, it should have been Luke 6:40.
2. Your comments to Armen. I am not speaking for him but couldn’t resist comenting!
I am not sure if you advocate the ordination of women? It seems like the under current to your comment.
If Christ is the head of His Church and the Church is His bride, Christ is masculine and the church feminine. The minister (bishop, elder etc.) is Christ’s representative to the Church. So, the minister represents the masculine Christ and the Church represents the feminine bride. This analogy of husband and wife breaks down as soon as you accept female ministers (elders etc).
To say that Jesus (or Paul for that matter)would not qualify if we actually used Scripture (i.e. 1 Tim. 3:2) is absurd! If we push the previous analogy, Jesus has one bride! Also, by stating you must be the husband of one wife does not by neccessity mean you must have a wife! Contextually the “one wife” phrase is refering to the problem of polygamy in first century Judaism, something Jesus highlighted as sinful. To stretch this to mean a man must have a wife is to say Paul was not consistent. He did say to the Corinthians that in that time of great tribulation that it was better not to take a wife.
I believe all of the qualifications for elder (etc) are clearly speaking towards men not women. To say we must apply these clear qualifications ad hoc is to deny the authority of the Scriptures. It also flies in the face of 1900 years of orthodox understanding.
I agree Trev with your points that as Christian parents especially fathers we NEED to be more focused and involved with the Christian childrens education.
They need to have a strong understanding and relationship already (with God and parents) when they go to school (secular or not).
In regards to the church being the ‘bride’ of Christ. This is another reason why Men dont like church. Which man wants to be a bride??? Not me…
I tend to agree. One of my biggest ‘issues’ with the church world is the music of today. Yesterdays worship music was all about God, the Blood, Jesus, the Holy Spirit etc but todays? Its all about me, I, we etc..
Perlapennylopes last blog post..Home Improvement Siding
Yes Perlapennylope, you are 100% correct that todays music is not about Jesus/ God/ Holy Spirit anymore. I much prefer singing amazing grace or one of the other older (more powerful) songs than todays fluffy Hillsong/ Planet Shaker songs created by females or effeminate guys.
I have touched on the state of todays worship in another of my posts that you may find interesting (http://www.germworks.net/when-worship-becomes-more-than-god/).
You also make mention of the “all about me” mindset. I am thinking about writing a post about this…
i have just read through your posts and found it very interesting.
I can only speak from my experience as a woman in regards to men and their role. The devil hates marriage and all of us and he will seek to destroy it and us anyway he can. i have seen a two fold shift- the woman rising up and the men submitting. It has not been a one way affair, the woman could not take the lead if the man remained the head. This goes back (in our situation) to the way we were raised as children. My family did not know God and both my parents were marraied 3 times, with lots of verbal and physical abuse. Hence we learnt how to surrive, repair cars, get water etc without a man around. Mum and us children were often left to fend for ourselves. This has made me a strong woman, which is OK and not an issue is if it is contained within a biblical framework. My husband came from a “christian” home where the father had undiagnosed mental health issues, his dad never taught him anything, just yelled at him. Hence his mum was their to pick up the pieces and made a woosy man- not his fault though. I longed for him to be the “head” of the home and he longed to lead, we just didnt know what was right and what was wrong, we had no teaching.
So we have had a hard time knowing what the biblical model was as not many these days teach it, and it is most definatly not taught in most churches. Praise God, he bought us into a might church where we have been show the biblical model and it has been hard at times but we are constantly growing into our biblical roles and loving it. Our whole family has blossomed from this change.
The scripture teaches us to “train up a child” that includes the roles and functions of a husband and wife, if we get it right at this level then the next generatin will keep perpetuating it and we will see change.
If reference to songs, you can go to http://www.sharesong.org and find songs for free to use in a church setting. they have a great variety and many “warfare” type songs.
In regards to “us being the “bride” read revelations 21:9 onwards. Do cross references.
@Sherrie – Interesting testimony and it does indeed back up what we have said with a real life situation.
I was also raised from a single mum for a good period of time.
What my mum did which imo helped was to get ‘other’ men in the church to take me to father/ son camps, build army bases for my army men, give me a toy gun etc. This is what is needed by men in the church when a single mum comes into the church. The men need to be a father figure.
Also what is interesting is that the spirit of feminism strengthens the females but weakens the men. The devil has indeed twisted it to weaken the church, marriage etc
Jermayns last blog post..The Best and the Worst of the World: The Tongue









[...] and understanding of today’s generation is a problem in today’s church, especially when Men are not present so lets focus on the last two points in taking risks and being an inward church. Church marketing [...]
[...] Muslims believe that when you martyr yourself you enjoy the everlasting company of seventy-two virgins. And the Mormons believe that faithful men spend eternity making celestial babies and are Gods of their own planets. It is no wonder that the Islam and Mormon faith have strong male dominance (read more: How the Church has failed men). [...]